About These Rules
This FAQ covers the most common Magic: The Gathering rules questions we see from players of all skill levels. All answers are based on the official MTG Comprehensive Rules and verified community sources.
For complex or unusual interactions: Use our MTG AI judge, Nissa, who can rule on intricate interactions, cite specific rule numbers, and provide examples from actual gameplay scenarios.
Note: While these answers are accurate for casual and most competitive play, always defer to a judge in sanctioned tournaments.
Basic Game Rules
How do I win a game of Magic: The Gathering?
You win by reducing your opponent's life total from 40 to 0, forcing them to draw from an empty library, or through specific card effects that state "you win the game" (like Thassa's Oracle). In Commander, you can also win by dealing 21 combat damage from a single commander.
What is the stack and how does it work?
The stack is a zone where spells and abilities wait to resolve. When you cast a spell or activate an ability, it goes on the stack. Players can respond by adding more spells/abilities on top. The stack resolves from top to bottom - the last thing added resolves first (Last In, First Out). This is why you can counter a spell before it takes effect.
What is priority and when do I get it?
Priority is your turn to take an action (cast a spell, activate an ability, or pass). The active player gets priority first at the start of each step and phase. After they pass priority, the non-active player gets it. Both players must pass priority in succession for the game to move to the next step or for something on the stack to resolve.
Can I respond to my own spells?
Yes! After you cast a spell, you retain priority and can respond to your own spell with instant-speed actions. This is useful for tricks like casting a creature, then responding with an instant that gives it haste before your opponent can respond.
Combat Rules
When can I cast instants during combat?
You can cast instants during any of the five combat steps: Beginning of Combat, Declare Attackers, Declare Blockers, Combat Damage, and End of Combat. The most common times are after attackers are declared (to tap/remove creatures) or after blockers are declared (to pump creatures or remove blockers).
If I kill a blocking creature before damage, does the attacker hit the player?
No. Once blockers are declared, removing a blocker does not make the attacker unblocked. The attacking creature will deal no damage (unless it has trample). To prevent this, you need to remove the blocker before the Declare Blockers step.
How does trample work?
Trample allows excess combat damage to carry over to the defending player. If your 5/5 trampler is blocked by a 2/2, you assign 2 damage to the blocker (lethal damage) and can assign the remaining 3 damage to the defending player. With multiple blockers, you must assign lethal to each before trampling over.
Can I attack with a creature that has summoning sickness?
No. A creature has summoning sickness if you haven't controlled it continuously since the beginning of your most recent turn. Creatures with summoning sickness can't attack or use abilities with the tap symbol. However, they can block and use abilities that don't require tapping.
What is first strike and how does it work?
First strike creates an additional combat damage step. Creatures with first strike deal damage before creatures without it. If a creature with first strike kills its blocker in first strike damage, the blocker won't deal damage back. Double strike means a creature deals damage in both the first strike and normal damage steps.
Card Interactions
What happens if I target a creature with hexproof?
You can't. Hexproof means "This permanent can't be the target of spells or abilities your opponents control." If you try to target a hexproof permanent your opponent controls, the spell/ability is illegal and can't be cast/activated. However, effects that don't target (like board wipes) still work.
What's the difference between 'destroy' and 'sacrifice'?
Destroy is an action done to a permanent by an external effect (like Murder). Indestructible creatures can't be destroyed. Sacrifice is an action the permanent's controller performs - you choose which creature to sacrifice. Indestructible creatures can be sacrificed, and sacrifice effects bypass hexproof and shroud.
Can I counter a creature ability?
It depends. You can counter activated and triggered abilities (using cards like Stifle or Disallow), but you cannot counter static abilities. For example, you can counter the triggered ability "When this enters, draw a card" but you can't counter the static ability "Creatures you control get +1/+1."
What is the difference between 'enters the battlefield' and 'cast'?
"Cast" triggers only when you cast the spell from your hand (or exile if allowed). "Enters the battlefield" triggers whenever the permanent enters, regardless of how (cast, reanimated, token created, etc.). This is why Panharmonicon doubles ETB effects but doesn't affect cast triggers.
How do +1/+1 and -1/-1 counters interact?
They cancel each other out as a state-based action. If a creature has three +1/+1 counters and receives two -1/-1 counters, they immediately remove each other, leaving one +1/+1 counter. They never coexist on the same permanent.
Commander-Specific Rules
How does Commander damage work?
Each commander deals its own separate "commander damage" to each opponent. If a single commander deals 21 or more combat damage to a player over the course of the game, that player loses. This damage is cumulative throughout the game and doesn't reset. Non-combat damage from commanders doesn't count.
What is the command zone?
The command zone is where your commander starts the game and returns to if it would be put into your hand, graveyard, library, or exile (you choose). You can cast your commander from the command zone, but it costs 2 more colorless mana for each previous time you've cast it (the "commander tax").
Can I use off-color mana abilities in Commander?
No. Commander has a strict color identity rule. You can't include cards with mana symbols outside your commander's color identity, and you can't produce mana of colors outside your commander's identity. If you try, that mana becomes colorless instead.
What happens if my commander gets exiled or phased out?
If your commander would be exiled, you can choose to move it to the command zone instead (but you don't have to). If your commander phases out, it stays phased out in the same zone - you can't move it to the command zone until it would change zones.
Advanced Rules
What is state-based action and when does it happen?
State-based actions are automatic game checks that happen whenever a player would receive priority. Examples include: creatures with 0 toughness die, players at 0 life lose, creatures with lethal damage die, +1/+1 and -1/-1 counters cancel. They happen simultaneously and don't use the stack.
How do replacement effects work?
Replacement effects watch for a specific event and replace it with a different event. They use words like "instead," "as," or "skip." For example, "If you would draw a card, instead..." Replacement effects don't use the stack and happen as the event occurs, not after.
What is the difference between 'may' and 'must' abilities?
Abilities with "may" are optional - you choose whether to perform them. Abilities without "may" are mandatory - you must perform them even if it's bad for you. For example, "Draw a card" is mandatory, while "You may draw a card" is optional.
How do layers work for continuous effects?
Layers determine the order continuous effects apply to a permanent. There are seven layers applied in order: copy, control, text, type, color, ability adding/removing, and power/toughness. This is why a creature that becomes a copy of another creature loses all modifications (like auras or equipment) in most cases.
MTG AI Judge: Rule Any Interaction
Have a question that isn't on this list? Paste your exact interaction and Nissa rules on it
The FAQ above covers the questions we see most often. For anything else, Nissa works as an MTG AI judge: describe a specific board state and question - a stack of triggers, a combat math puzzle, a layers interaction, or a Commander color-identity edge case - and she returns a clear ruling citing the official Comprehensive Rules, RulesGuru, and the MTG Stack Exchange. Because she reasons from rules text and real Scryfall card data, she can rule on brand-new cards and interactions she has never been asked about before, not just a fixed list of questions.
Great For
Settling casual and Commander-pod disputes, learning why a ruling is what it is, checking an interaction mid-deckbuild, and prepping before an event. Every ruling cites its source so you can confirm it yourself.
See a Certified Judge For
Sanctioned tournament rulings, missed-trigger and game-state policy, and penalties. The AI judge explains the rules and cites them, but it is not a tournament authority - at competitive events, always defer to a certified human judge.
MTG AI Judge FAQ
Can an AI judge a Magic: The Gathering interaction?
Yes. Describe the cards, the board state, and your question, and Nissa identifies the relevant rules and applies them to your exact scenario - stack order, combat math, layers, and replacement effects. Every ruling cites the Comprehensive Rules so you can verify it.
Is the AI judge's ruling official for tournaments?
No. The AI judge is for casual play, learning, and settling kitchen-table or Commander-pod disputes. For sanctioned events, missed-trigger policy, and penalties, always defer to a certified human judge. Nissa explains and cites the rules, but it is not a tournament authority.
Does the AI judge cite the actual rules?
Yes. Every ruling points to its source - a Comprehensive Rules number, a RulesGuru entry, or an MTG Stack Exchange thread - so you can confirm the answer yourself and learn the reasoning behind it.
Explore More
Commander Deck Building Guide
Learn how to build optimized EDH decks with proper card ratios, mana curves, and synergies.
AI Deck Builder
Let Karn build and optimize your deck using real card data from Scryfall.
How It Works
Learn how our multi-agent AI system provides accurate rules answers with cited sources.
Last updated: